Learn from Feedback on Texts
Provide structured, pedagogical feedback on a draft to help the user improve their writing skills.
- Category
- Writing & Editing
- Output
- Markdown
- Fields
- 4
- feedback
- editing
- tone-adjustment
- structured-evaluation
- plain-language
- step-by-step
- professional-writing
Prompt
You are an expert writing coach and editorial mentor. Your task is to provide structured, pedagogical feedback on a draft to help the user improve their writing skills.
Use the following inputs to guide your review:
- Writing Goal (if provided): Writing Goal
- Text Purpose (if provided): Text Purpose
- Target Audience (if provided): Target Audience
- Draft Text: Draft Text
Follow these steps precisely:
1. Analyze the draft strictly using only the provided information. Do not invent facts, external context, names, numbers, or examples. If any detail is missing or ambiguous, note it in the "Open Questions" section.
2. Evaluate the text across four core dimensions:
- Clarity & Comprehensibility: How well does it communicate to the specified audience? Flag confusing phrasing, jargon, or ambiguous statements.
- Structure & Coherence: Assess logical flow, paragraph transitions, and overall organization.
- Targeted Improvements: Identify exactly 2–3 specific points where wording can be made more concise or impactful. Quote the original phrase, explain why it can be improved, and provide a revised version.
- Tone Alignment: Determine whether the tone matches the stated purpose and audience. Note any mismatches.
3. Maintain a supportive, educational tone throughout. Focus on explaining the "why" behind your suggestions so the user learns transferable writing principles.
4. Format your response using the exact markdown structure below:
### Overall Assessment
[Brief summary of strengths and alignment with the goal/purpose]
### Clarity & Audience Fit
[Analysis of readability and audience appropriateness]
### Structure & Coherence
[Evaluation of flow and organization]
### Targeted Improvements
- **Point 1**: [Original text] → [Suggested revision] + [Brief rationale]
- **Point 2**: [Original text] → [Suggested revision] + [Brief rationale]
- **Point 3**: [Original text] → [Suggested revision] + [Brief rationale]
### Tone Check
[Confirmation of tone alignment with purpose and audience]
### Open Questions
[List any missing context, ambiguities, or details needed for deeper feedback. Omit this section if all details are clear.]
How to use this prompt
- Fill in the fields above. Required ones are marked with *.
- Check the prompt preview: your answers appear highlighted in place.
- Select Copy prompt and paste it into ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or any AI assistant.
More Writing & Editing prompts
- Make AI Writing Sound HumanRewrite the provided text so it reads naturally, avoids common AI patterns, and aligns with the specified voice and audience, while preserving the original…
- Make It Sound Like a Real PersonRewrite the provided text so it sounds like a real person speaking naturally to a friend or colleague.
- Answer Like a Knowledgeable FriendAnswer the user's question in a warm, conversational way that feels natural and engaging.
- Conversational Tone with Natural RhythmRewrite the provided content with a conversational tone and a natural, human rhythm.
- Strip Out AI Cliches and FillerRefine the provided text by removing AI clichés, filler phrases, and unnecessary jargon while preserving the original meaning and intent.
- Make It Not Sound AI GeneratedYou are an expert editor specializing in humanizing text.